← D.C. Law 26-37 · All reviewed explanations

D.C. Law 26-37 · DC District of Columbia · Section 2

When a reviewing tribunal must defer to an agency interpretation

When it was enacted

Enacted 2025-07-21 · Effective 2025-09-10 · Permanent law.

Official record dates

Before

The actual pre-September-10, 2025 Code already included deference provisions from temporary Law 25-290, effective March 7 for 225 days, following emergency Act 25-634. Those provisions covered reasonable interpretations by the Mayor or an agency, subject to plainly-wrong and text/intent limits. The permanent act therefore does not first create all agency deference. Its wording expressly addresses statutory or rule silence/ambiguity on the particular issue, adds reasonableness factors and uses agency rather than the earlier Mayor-or-agency phrasing.

Earlier official source

After

For review of an agency order or decision in any court or administrative proceeding, the tribunal must defer to the agency's reasonable interpretation of a statute or rule it administers when that statute or rule is silent or ambiguous on the specific issue, provided the interpretation is not plainly wrong or inconsistent with the text or the legislature's or agency's intent. For review of an adopted agency rule, the comparable duty concerns the agency's interpretation of a statute it administers, with silence/ambiguity, reasonableness and statutory text/legislative-intent limits. In assessing reasonableness, the tribunal may consider consistency and longevity of the interpretation, agency expertise on the issue, and how thoroughly and formally the agency considered it. These are nonexclusive considerations, not three mandatory findings. The court's subsection (a)(1) authority to decide legal questions is made subject to these provisions.

Enacted source

In plain English

Deference means giving controlling weight to an agency interpretation that satisfies the stated conditions; it does not mean an agency wins every dispute. The order/decision route includes interpretation of an administered rule as well as a statute; the adopted-rule route addresses the administered statute. The act retains the surrounding judicial-review powers, including setting aside unlawful action, constitutional violations, excess authority, procedural failures and findings unsupported by substantial evidence. It does not itself create a new appeal deadline, automatically suspend enforcement or replace the existing contested-case review route. The new clauses refer to an agency rather than expressly repeating Mayor or agency; no conclusion about a particular mayoral act or entity's statutory classification is made here. This historical enacted-text comparison does not claim a complete review of earlier common law, the Loper Bright decision, later cases or a particular appeal.

Timing and applicability

Recorded effective September 10, 2025. Earlier temporary Law 25-290 had its own 225-day duration and overlapped this permanent enactment; emergency Act 25-634 had a separate no-longer-than-90-day term. No uninterrupted-history, retroactivity or outcome in a pending case is inferred. Complete current-law and judicial-interpretation review remain unfinished.

Explanation reviewed 2026-10-27.

Read the official section text
2 Section 110 of the District of Columbia Administrative Procedure Act, approved October 21, 1968 (82 Stat. 1209; D.C. Official Code § 2-510), is amended as follows: (a) Subsection (a)(1) is amended by striking the phrase "So far as necessary" and inserting the phrase "Subject to subsections (c), (d), and (e) of this section and so far as necessary" in its place. (b) New subsections (c), (d), and (e) are added to read as follows: (c) In reviewing an order or decision of an agency in any court or administrative proceeding, including proceedings under subsection (a) of this section, the reviewing tribunal shall defer to the agency's reasonable interpretation of a statute or rule it administers, when the statute or rule is silent or ambiguous with respect to a specific issue; provided, that the interpretation is not plainly wrong or inconsistent with either the statute's or rule's language or the legislature's or agency's intent. (d) In reviewing a rule adopted by an agency, the reviewing tribunal shall defer to the agency's reasonable interpretation of a statute it administers, when the statute is silent or ambiguous with respect to a specific issue; provided, that the interpretation is not plainly wrong or inconsistent with either the statute's language or the legislature's intent. (e) In determining whether an interpretation by an agency is reasonable under subsection (c) or (d) of this section, the reviewing tribunal may consider, among other factors: (1) Whether the interpretation provided by an agency has been consistent and longstanding; (2) Whether the specific issue is within the scope of the agency's subject matter-expertise; and (3) The thoroughness and formality of the agency's consideration. .
Pinned official bulk source

Interpretations & later changes

Later-law and court review may be incomplete. Absence of an entry does not establish that the original provision remains in force.

No separately reviewed later development is published here yet.

Read the complete law guide and review status